The coming of age novel is a timeless trope
because it is a guaranteed universal experience. Everyone has had that
experience where they realize that the adult world is far different and far
more complicated than that of a child. This transition often includes a loss of
innocence, but in a horror coming of age tale, that loss of innocence is
practically guaranteed, once the protagonist realizes that there are many
things out there in the adult world with very sharp teeth. Heather, the
protagonist in Damien Angelica Walter’s The Dead Girls Club, must deal with a loss of innocence that haunts her well
into adulthood.
The story has two narratives. The first has
Heather at 12, who enjoys hanging out with her friends, especially her best
friend Becca, about serial killers and the Red Lady, a ghost story that
develops an unlife of its own. The other has Heather as a child psychologist
who receives a heart-shaped pendant in the mail that once belonged to Becca
before she died. What follows is a descent into paranoia for Heather as she realizes
someone knows of her involvement in Becca’s death and a mystery as to whether
or not she is being haunted by the Red Lady. By looking at Heather’s past and
her friendship with the members of the Dead Girls Club, readers are pulled
along as the book teases us with what happened to Becca, along with a breakneck
conclusion that tantalizingly leaves the reality of the Red Lady. Is she still
fiction or is she much more?
This ambiguity of supernatural forces, a prime
example of this being Paul Tremblay’s A Head Full of Ghosts, may confuse some readers but it ultimately adds to the
story’s power. A cold spot in a house can be explained away by drafts and the
creaking in an old house could just be the structure settling, but when the
protagonist hears a house groan in almost human tones or feels a chill where
there are no windows, their mind starts to race as they search for an
explanation. When none is satisfactory, the only options left are for the
protagonist to feed the ghost by giving it a reality in his or her head or to
accept the ambiguity. Tremblay and Walters understand that supernatural
malevolence, whether in a house or a spooky story, is given power by the people
who experience it and retell it.